Is your house an asset?

Opinion is divided on whether your house is an asset based on who you ask. Some financial planners recommend that you make your investment plan first, save for a house, buy it only when the rent vs buy equation makes complete sense, and treat the monthly payment as a pure expense (after accounting for tax deductions). Some others say that a house is an investment, and even better than stocks as it is not risky and volatile, and you generally will not lose your money there.


Like most matters in finance, there is no single answer – but here is an attempt to simplify the thought process. In pure accounting terms, a house is an asset on your books, funded partly by the loan liability. The real question that should be asked is whether it is a good investment? In most cases, it turns out to be a good investment, simply because the asset on your books appreciates faster than both the cost of your liability and inflation. But whether it really happens at a rate where it qualifies as a good investment depends on a multiple set of factors.

(a) Price that you paid for it: Like economic cycles, housing goes through boom and bust cycles, though not as severe as stocks. Hence, the price at which you buy a house is paramount, like all other investments, in deciding whether it will turn out to be a good investment. As it is a high value asset that most people hold for a long time, most people pay much more attention to the price they pay for a house, versus what they pay for a stock. But nevertheless, it is still the single most important factor in determining if it will turn out to be a good investment.

(b) Loan to Value ratio: Leverage (or mortgage) has a definite role to play in the house purchase. The higher the loan component, the higher the chances that the investment will be not be lucrative in a short period of time. The more you can put down in payment, the more (and earlier) you are converting your cash into a share in an asset that will eventually fight inflation.

(c) Your cost of funding versus inflation or expected rate of growth: If the expected rate of return from a house is about 1-2% more than the rate of inflation, and the cost of funding is lower, that is a perfect scenario where buying a house using borrowed funds will turn out to be a good investment. Specially over longer periods where the power of compounded asset value will surpass the cost of the loan liability.  And if one regularly prepays it in the initial stages, one will save lots of interest in the long run.

(d) Last but not the least, where does it fit in your asset allocation: Finally, as compared to your income and net worth, the proportion that you have locked in a house will also determine how comfortable you are with buying the house, the more likely it is that you will take a financially sound decision, hence increasing its chances of working out as an investment.

So overall, multiple factors will go into deciding whether a house will turn out to be a good investment. In a best case scenario, buying a house at a reasonable price with less than 75% leverage at a leverage cost less than or close to inflation, and ensuring that it does not account for more than 40% of assets is almost a sure-shot recipe for a house being a great investment. For most mortals, it may not turn out to be that rosy – in which case one or more of these parameters are likely to get stretched, leading to some financial bleeding, at least for a while.

In general, irrespective of the pure financial matters and even discounting the emotional security it provides, a house is definitely likely to be a worthwhile investment for most normal individual investors if they are prudent in ensuring they balance the above factors in their purchase. As most house purchases are held for long periods, they invariably turn out to be good investments standalone.  They may lead to some missed opportunities due to locked capital, but that’s another matter. After all, I never saw a house owner of 10 years saying I really regret having bought my house. And there’s no dearth of stock owners saying that!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: